The Role of Worship: Wesleyan Catechesis, part 8April 25th, 2011
This blog completes an eight part series on the distinctive of Wesleyan catechesis. These blogs on catechesis are actually part of a larger project I am exploring through my blogs as to how we rebuild the meta-narrative in the church today. One of the earliest writers to recognize the collapse of modernity as we in the post-Enlightenment world understood it was the French philosopher Jean-François Lyotard in his 1979 article entitled, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. In the article, he coined the word “post-modern” (the term had actually been used by several others even in the 19th century, but not in the way it is used today) and stated what has now been observed by dozens of writers in the subsequent years and that is that the fundamental reality of our time as Western civilization is a growing crisis of truth. In the modern world there was a belief in an overarching truth – whether informed by a Christian world-view or even a secular belief in progress and the perfectibility of humanity. Lyotard argued that modern societies produced order and stability by generating what he called “grand narratives” or “master narratives.” In America, for example, one “grand narrative” is that democracy is the most enlightened and rational form of government and that implementing of democracy will lead to universal happiness. In contrast, the Marxist “grand narrative” posited that capitalism was collapsing in on itself and that, in time – and spurred by revolution – a utopian socialist world order would evolve.
In the post-modern context, we are only on a virtual voyage where one explores self-created worlds. Post-modernism marks the movement away from claims to objectivity and a greater emphasis on fragmented forms and discontinuous narratives. In short, the very notion of truth as Truth has begun to collapse.
Christians know that the only true “grand canopy” of meaning is found in the great redemptive work of God in the world. However, tragically, today’s church can all too easily become co-opted by the self-referential, consumer driven, emotive oriented forces which are present in the wider society. Nowhere has this become more evident than in contemporary worship. There are, of course, some wonderful, truly wonderful, new choruses and hymns being written today. There is also quite a bit of chaff in the midst of the wheat. We must recognize afresh that the “worship wars” is not a struggle between hymns versus choruses, any more than in Wesley’s day it was over Psalms versus hymns. The struggle must be focused on the fact that we worship the living God and all worship is a response to His revelation.
This is, of course, the crowning piece in Wesleyan catechesis: The centrality of Worship. Wesleyans sing their theology! Wesley knew that it is not enough merely to believe and to confess, we must enter into the very presence of the Triune God in worship. Worship is one of the main ways Wesley forged the great meta-narrative of God’s redemption into the lives of new disciples. Charles Wesley wrote thousands of hymns to capture the great truths of the Christian faith. If we are to engage in serious catechesis today we must not neglect the renewal of worship. Our worship must be Trinitarian, theologically rich, memorable and, most of all, faithful to the entire meta-narrative.
 Jean-Francois Lyotard, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge (MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1985).
Please fill out the form below if you would like to provide feedback to Dr. Tennent concerning this blog entry.