Jesus Christ is Risen! An Examination of Creeds and ConfessionsApril 10th, 2012
As we celebrate Easter we are all reminded afresh about what lies at the heart of Christian faith; namely, that Jesus Christ bodily rose from the dead, triumphing over evil, sin and death. St. Paul declares that if Jesus Christ is not risen we are still in our sins and our preaching is useless (I Cor. 15:12-20). This is why it is so important that Christians regularly confess the historic creeds of the faith (Apostles’ Creed and Nicene Creed). These creeds remind us of the heart of the Christian faith. I am amazed at the quiet disappearance of Creeds in many worship services today.
To see the value of a creed we must first understand the difference between a creed and a confession of faith. A creed is a historic declaration of the faith which unites all Christians throughout the world and across the annals of time. It is, if I can use the word, an ecumenical statement, i.e. it is for the whole “house of faith.” A confession of faith, on the other hand, may emphasize certain beliefs that a particular group of Christians want to emphasize but does not unite the whole house of faith.
Take, for example, the collections at the back of the United Methodist hymnal. The UMC hymnal has nine “confessions” all under the general heading “Affirmations of Faith.” What follows, more precisely, are the two creeds (Nicene and Apostles), four confessions of faith (United Church of Canada, Korean Methodist church, a Modern affirmation and the World Methodist Social Affirmation), and, finally, there are three affirmations from three passages of Scripture (from Romans 8, Colossians 1 and I Timothy). It is rather unfortunate that no explanation is given as to the vital differences between these.
The United Church of Canada statement has a rather vague statement of the incarnation, is not explicitly Trinitarian, and totally omits the ascension of Jesus Christ. The Korean Methodist church statement boldly confesses that Jesus Christ is the “redeemer and savior of the world” but curiously omits the crucifixion of Christ, the resurrection of Christ, and the ascension of Christ. It would be hard to reconstruct the meta-narrative of the New Testament if one only had the Korean Methodist Church statement. The Modern Affirmation likewise omits the crucifixion, resurrection and the ascension of Christ. The World Methodist Social Affirmation confuses the two uses of the word “confession.” It begins as a “confession” meaning a declaration of faith, but then drifts into a “confession” about how we have not lived up to the truth of the gospel through our sin, violation of human dignity, exploitation of people, etc. It is, of course, a good thing to confess our sins publicly (see earlier blogs on this point), but a confession of faith is supposed to be about what He has done, not what we have not done. The Scriptural affirmations are, of course, wonderful and should be used in public worship. We need more Scripture read, not less.
Thus, my word of advice on this collection at the back of the United Methodist Hymnal is that United Methodist churches should politely avoid using any of the four confessions in public worship. They are simply too weak theologically to sustain the faith of the church and they do not unite us with the church throughout the world and back in time. Instead, we should include as a normal component of worship a creed, Nicene or Apostles, or a Scriptural affirmation (Romans 8, Colossians 1, or 1Timothy).
Please fill out the form below if you would like to provide feedback to Dr. Tennent concerning this blog entry.