Dr. Tim Tennent’s response to Dr. Kinghorn’s article:
Reading Dr. Kinghorn’s article is a wonderful and refreshing experience. In this lucid and insightful article, Kinghorn reminds us all why the Wesleyan tradition is such a rich and beautiful tradition. There are two things which I deeply appreciated in the article: First, his emphasis on Wesley’s commitment to historic Christian faith. We live in a day when many in the church take delight in the novelty of their new doctrinal positions. It is all too common to sit in a church today and hear novel doctrines expounded from the pulpit. Kinghorn reminds us that Wesley advocated no “new” gospel, but the historic Christian faith which was “once for all entrusted to the saints” (Jude 3). Wesley was unshakeable in his commitment to the authority of Scripture, the supremacy of Christ and the sole sufficiency of the Christian gospel. This is a message for all time and every culture.
Second, I appreciated the emphasis on the catholicity of Wesley’s message. Precisely because Wesley had such a firm grasp on the great core truths of the faith which all Christians share, he was able to draw strength from a wide variety of Christian traditions. Wesley was as much at home with the Patristics and Reformers as he was with the Pietists and the Puritans. Wesley was not a sectarian and would have decried the kind of provincial denominationalism which so frequently plagues Christian ministries today. As we emerge into the bright light of global Christianity, Wesley’s dual commitment to orthodoxy and catholicity will serve us well as Asbury Theological Seminary prepares ministers to be faithful to Christ and the gospel in the 21st century.
Dr. Ken Kinghorn – Asbury Theological Seminary and the Wesleyan Message
John Wesley invented no new theological doctrines. “Whatever doctrine is new must be wrong” he wrote, “and no doctrine can be right, unless it is the very same ‘which was from the beginning.’” 1 Mr. Wesley said, “If Methodism…be a new discovery in religion…this [notion] is a grievous mistake; we pretend no such thing.” 2 Far from being narrowly sectarian, John Wesley was a catholic Christian. He stood firmly in the main stream of historic Christianity, and drew from many of the tributaries that fed into it.
(1) Early Church Writers. John Wesley often referred to “Primitive Christianity,” that is, the Church from the end of the apostolic age to the early fourth century. Christian writers in this era helped confirm the biblical canon, the doctrine of the Trinity, and the mystery of the Incarnation, through which the eternal Christ entered time and space as fully human and fully God. Mr. Wesley said of those early, “primitive” Christians, “I reverence their writings, because they describe true, genuine Christianity…. They never relinquish this: ‘What the Scripture promises, I enjoy. That the God of power and love may make you, and me, such Christians as those Fathers were, is [my] earnest prayer.” 3
(2) The Protestant Reformation. John Wesley was a Protestant, who believed the Medieval Church had allowed layers of nonbiblical tradition to cloud the gospel of grace. Accumulated ecclesiastical inventions compelled the sixteenth-century Reformation. The Wesleyan message harmonizes with the fundamental themes of the Protestant Reformers, who recovered the supremacy of Scripture above human conventions. The essence of Protestantism is that salvation comes through grace alone, faith alone, and Christ alone. Wesley wrote, “We have all reason to expect . . . ‘that [Christ] should come unto us quickly, and remove our candlestick out of its place, except we repent and…unless we return to the principles of the Reformation, the truth and simplicity of the gospel.” 4
(3) Pietism. The Wesleyan tradition also borrows from the seventeenth-century German Pietists. Those earnest Christians championed the individual’s personal knowledge of Christ, serious discipleship, Christian witness, missions, and social ministries. Wesley referred to the Pietist August Francke as one “whose name is indeed as precious ointment. O may I follow him, as he did Christ!” 5 From the Moravian Pietists, the early Wesleyan movement appropriated such means of grace as class meetings, conferences, vigils, and Love-feasts.
(4) The Mystics. The influence of certain aspects of mysticism further reveals the catholicity of the Wesleyan message. John Wesley’s reading of Thomas à Kempis led him first to see that “true religion was seated in the heart, and that God’s law extended to all our thoughts as well as our words and actions.” Jeremy Taylor’s Rule and Exercises of Holy Living (1650) and Rule and Exercises of Holy Dying (1651) and William Law’s Serious Call to a Devout and Holy Life (1728) convinced Wesley of “the exceeding height and depth and breadth of…God.” 6
The mystics also helped Wesley understand the Christian’s privilege of knowing the inner witness of the Holy Spirit. He wrote, “The light flowed in so mightily upon my soul, that every thing appeared in a new view….I was persuaded that I should be accepted of Him, and that I was even then in a state of salvation.” 7
(5) The Puritans. The Wesleyan message also bears the influence of the Puritan divines, such as John Owen, Thomas Goodwin, and Richard Baxter. These prodigious writers highlighted the profound depths of grace, God’s call to purity, and living daily in the light of eternity. “Their judgment is generally deep and strong,” said John Wesley, “their sentiments just and clear, and their tracts on every head full and comprehensive, exhausting the subjects on which they write…. They are men mighty in the Scriptures, equal to any of those who went before them, and far superior to most that have followed them.” 8
The Power of the Wesleyan Witness. All valid Christian traditions preach that justification and adoption give repentant sinners a new standing, in which God imputes Christ’s righteousness to us and frees us from the guilt of sin. The Wesleyan message also emphasizes that regeneration and sanctification give us a new state, in which God imparts Christ’s righteousness to us and frees us from the power of sin. The treasures of the Wesleyan message, have never been more relevant than today.
1 Sermon #13, “On Sin in Believers,” Bicentennial ed., §3, ¶ 9, 1:324.
2 Works, Jackson ed., 3:37.
3 Letter to Dr. Middleton, 24 Jan. 1749, Works, Jackson ed., 10:79.
4 Works, Bicentennial ed., 1:15.
5 Works, Jackson ed., 1:112.
6 John Wesley’s Journals and Diaries, 24 May 1938, Bicentennial ed., 18:243.
8 John Wesley, Extracts from the Works of the Puritans, 7:2. Works, Jackson ed., 14:229