Imprecatory Psalms: Are All the Psalms Suitable for Christian Use?

Thursday, November 1st, 2012

For the past two years, my wife Julie and I have started each day by singing a Psalm and then carefully thinking and praying through the Psalm line by line. We use a collection of metrical psalms known as the Trinity Psalter which draws from many of the great historic metrical Psalm collections (such as the famous Scottish Psalter) as well as new metrical renditions of the Psalms.  This has been a very enriching experience in our walk with the Lord.  Julie and I have also been slowly working on our own metrical Psalm collection, putting each Psalm into meter.  We hope to have this completed in the next few years (we haven’t yet tossed the coin to see who is going to take on Psalm 119!).

When people hear that we are singing the Psalms they sometimes ask, “Do you really sing them all?  Surely you mean the “old favorites” like Psalm 19, 23, 93, 100, right?”  “Surely,” they continue, “you as a Christian can’t sing Psalms like 109 and 137, can you?”

Psalm 109 and 137 are two of approximately eighteen Psalms that are considered imprecatory Psalms, i.e. they call down curses or judgment on someone (See, Psalms 5, 6, 11, 12, 35, 37, 40, 52, 54, 56, 58, 69, 79, 83, 109, 137, 139 and 143).  This raises a great question which is not just about singing Psalms, but preaching or reading the Psalms as well.

Are all the Psalms suitable for Christian use?

How do we reconcile the tension between, on the one hand, our confidence that “all Scripture is inspired by God and profitable, etc.” with our equal confidence that we should bless, not curse, our enemies?  That is the question which I would like to address.

First, all such honest, transparently painful cries found in the Psalms are cries of truth and faith.  The Psalmist turns their cries and pleas to God to act precisely because they know that it is not their place to do so.  We give up our own desire for human vengeance (unlike Islamic terrorism, or personal vendettas, etc.) and put vindication into God’s hands who alone judges and dispenses true justice.  The Apostles quote Psalm 109 after the betrayal of Judas so that they would not be trapped in personal unforgiveness, but rather put the whole matter into God’s hands.

Second, all the Psalms of imprecation point to our ultimate enemy, Satan.  It is true that we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but we do wrestle against the powers and principalities of whom the flesh and blood are but minions and servants (Eph.6:12).  So this great enemy, this perpetrator of evil and injustice and death and rebellion against the Lord, rightly prompts our passionate cries for the Lord’s action – to end this night of darkness and death which the enemy has unleashed into this world, and to set things right again.  The ravages of depression in the lives of those you love, the tyranny of poverty and injustice willfully imposed by wealthy dictators upon the poor, the horrors of rape and torture enacted upon innocent victims, the bondages of addiction which entrap and destroy healthy lives and families – all of these “enemies” are the tangible outworking of principalities and powers against which we cry with the psalmist for the Lord to wipe out and deliver us from.

Third, we must never forget that as Christians we read all Scripture in the presence of the Risen Christ.  Even those Psalms which call curses down upon our enemies point to God’s answer in Jesus Christ.  God’s judgment has come, his wrath has been poured out, his vengeance has been paid – and all of it has fallen upon Christ.  Every cry for vindication and vengeance, every curse and desire for “payback” which the psalmist wants to see has come upon Christ on the cross.  Thus, every verse of a psalm which utters a curse is actually a window into the cost and pain of God’s own answer; and a proclamation (of sorts) of the incredible grace of the gospel whereby the wrath and justice of God (of which the psalmist only feels a very small measure) is willingly taken upon Himself.  Christ became a curse for us – our redemption is there pictured.  In the gospel we also come face to face with the depth of our own sinfulness.

Finally, the vivid language of the imprecatory Psalms expresses our hope as believers that there will be a final end to evil, and that it will be destroyed to rise again no more (Rev. 18).  One of the most vivid images in the imprecatory Psalms is found in Psalm 137:8,9 when the Psalmist prays a blessing on those who take a woman’s child and dashes its head upon the rocks.  The imagery is one which God Himself had given as a promise in Isaiah 13:16.  The birth of another generation of Babylonians (who the Psalmist sees perpetuating unspeakable horrors against the people of God) is a sign of the ongoing perpetuation of evil.  The birth of an infant represents a pseudo “new creation” by the Babylonians which must, in the end, give way to the biblical new creation where evil comes to an end and is destroyed with no offspring to rise up again to take up the mantle of evil.  The Psalmist reminds us that there will be an end to the evil in the world.  God is going to set things right.  History as we know it does have an end.  He will come again to judge the world, destroy all evil and usher in the New Creation.

So, for these reasons, I encourage Christians to sing all the Psalms, including the Psalms of imprecation.  The whole Bible is inspired by God and every line of it is profitable for “teaching, rebuking, correction and training in righteousness” (2 Tim. 3:16).  So, I’m going to keep on singing the Psalms – all 150 of them.

Comments

  • Howard says:

    How refreshing! How insightful! How inspiring! PTL

  • Janni Martin says:

    What a masterful exposition of the imprecatory Psalms! Really enjoyed it – and have great memories of our class at TFC!

  • [...] http://timothytennent.com/2012/11/01/imprecatory-psalms-are-all-the-psalms-suitable-for-christian-us... Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in Uncategorized by sarhodes. Bookmark the permalink. [...]

  • Stephen says:

    Minor point, but 2 Tim 3.16 was not referring to the whole Bible. At the time that verse was written, the whole Bible was not compiled. That verse is only referring to OT scriptures.

  • jon says:

    I love this post! I preached through some of the Psalms this summer and made it a point to cover both easy and hard – Psalm 137 was by far the hardest one I covered. Putting it in it’s context was key and once that was explained, I touched upon much of what you said in your first point. I also said that the psalm was about honoring God’s name and the original psalmist would understand that happening through violence. However, for the Christian, we understand that happening through following the way of the cross. We honor God’s name through seeking to be a people of grace and forgiveness.

  • All of the above observations lead me to the conclusion that the imprecatory psalms are far more relevant and applicable to Christians today than we would like to admit. Why then are we so uneasy about them? Essentially I think the answer is that we have a distorted view of God, perverted by our own sin. We want to think of God only in terms of love and mercy, but not in terms of justice and judgment. We are soft on sin. I think we have become entangled in a satanic conspiracy. We have adopted the thinking summarized by the expression, “I’m O.K., You’re O.K.” If you will pardon me for doing so, I could entitle Psalm 109 , “I’m O.K., but You’re Not.” Such was the conviction of the psalmist. Most of us know that we are not O.K. Therefore we respond by going easy on others, hoping our laxity will make things easier on us. Let me tell you that if we had the courage and the conviction to pray as David did, we would be very ill at ease in regard to our own sins. Our greatest problem with imprecatory psalms is that the psalmist takes sin much more seriously than we do.

  • Matt Glover says:

    Psalms 109 and 137 are fantastic in corporate worship when you’ve invited non-believers or your parents who are hostile to reformed theology. It really draws them to the love of Christ.

    I think you need to be careful with your advice.

    Just because they are inspired doesn’t automatically make them helpful or useful in every situation.

    I’m not about to start a bible study on Ezekiel 23:20 with my 12 year old daughter any time soon. Yes, it is inspired and without error. But it is just not suitable at this point in her life.

    Imprecatory Psalms may possibly be suitable to be sung privately by someone with deep compassion and mature understanding of scripture.

    Recommending them for general use is just reckless, brother.

  • [...] Timothy Tennent recenlty blogged Imprecatory Psalms: Are All the Psalms Suitable for Christian Use? In a similar vein, The Gospel Coalition urges us not to “sanitize the [...]

  • I think that we must proceed with caution; just because the Babylonians were representative of evil in the world in the eyes of the Hebrews, that does not preclude the author of the Psalm from writing a Psalm in which he imagines the actual children having their heads smashed upon rocks.

    The scriptures are inspired, yet they are written in fallible human language. We do not have the ability to represent infallible, perfect revelation in our languages! God, therefore, is expressed in the language of the people, and during a time such as the people spent in the exile, this language is fully expected. We must not let it shape our view of God as one who encourages people to bash children’s heads on rocks, for he surely does not, he never has and never will!

  • Timothy, I thought this was an encouraging post. I had thought to write something of my own here to add to your voice. But it was starting to be too long to add as a comment. I’ll send you a link when I have it finished and you may be kind enough to comment on it in return.